Jimmy appears in Stan's story, "Hands Off," in "Little Gift Shop of Horrors," asking a handless Stan to play "toss a dozen eggs" with him like they usually do. Though Stan declines, due to his crude replacement hands being of limited use, Jimmy tosses them anyway, much to Stan's chagrin.
Jimmy seems to be quite enthusiastic and perky, as he happily chats with Stan. Conversely, he appears to be quite persistent and at times unaware of others, as Stan thoroughly insists he refuses to play their game.
Jimmy appears to be in his late teens. He has pale skin, brown hair, a large pink nose, freckles on his cheeks, and seems to have buck teeth. He is seen wearing a turquoise t-shirt and blue pants with a white apron over it.